4Capital and Performance

 

By Dr. Alex Liu

 

 

 




Chapter 2: New Capitalism Needs 4Capital

 

Modern capitalism—sometimes called “new capitalism”—cannot be understood by material wealth alone. Rapid technological change, globalization, and platform-based economies have shifted how value is created and sustained. In this environment, a balanced combination of material, intellectual, social, and spiritual capitals is not only a path to success but a requirement for long-term survival.

The evolution of capitalism and the rise of a holistic view


New Capitalism Demands for 4CapitalEarlier thinking equated progress with money, machines, and physical assets. As knowledge, networks, and values proved essential to innovation and cohesion, the concept of capital expanded. Thinkers such as Lawrence M. Miller described how a new capitalism must integrate culture, ethics, leadership, and learning with finance and production.

Material capital: still the foundation, but not sufficient


Material capital—funds, equipment, infrastructure, energy, and natural resources—remains essential. Yet over-reliance on financial metrics has often missed broader needs, producing fragility, inequality, and environmental stress. Recent shocks remind us that resilient material systems must be built in concert with the other capitals.

Intellectual capital: knowledge assets and adaptability


Education, research, data, software, and protected know-how drive competitiveness. Intellectual capital helps societies and organizations adapt to technological shifts. In today’s economy, data and AI models are prominent forms of intellectual assets; they are most productive when guided by clear purpose and embedded in a learning culture.

Social capital: trust, norms, and cooperation
Societies function through networks of trust and reciprocity. Social capital reduces friction, spreads good ideas, and supports collective action. Bonding ties build reliability; bridging ties connect to new opportunities and resilience. Without trust, even well-funded initiatives stall.

Spiritual capital: values, meaning, and direction


Spiritual capital highlights resources drawn from faith, purpose, and moral standards. For believers, it can be connectedness with God. For others, it is commitment to noble purposes and ethics. When values guide behavior and habits, they become usable capital that supports integrity, courage, and long-term orientation. Authors such as Danah Zohar have helped articulate this dimension.

Why 4Capital is necessary in new capitalism
Prosperity and social harmony are strongest when all four capitals are cultivated together. Material investment builds capacity; intellectual capital turns ideas into improvements; social capital enables cooperation; spiritual capital keeps power and ingenuity directed at worthy goals. Overemphasis on any single capital—money without trust, knowledge without ethics, or community without resources—creates new problems.

Everyday examples (brief)
• A manufacturer invests in energy-efficient equipment (material) and worker training (intellectual) while building supplier partnerships (social) under a clear purpose to reduce waste (spiritual).
• A city upgrades broadband (material), publishes open data (intellectual), and co-designs programs with community groups (social) guided by a shared vision of inclusion (spiritual).

Applies across systems
These principles hold in capitalist or socialist settings. The four capitals describe how value is created and sustained in any society—through resources, ideas, relationships, and values.

Conclusion
The 4Capital approach provides a comprehensive map for navigating new capitalism and beyond. By acknowledging the interdependence of material, intellectual, social, and spiritual capitals, societies can strengthen innovation, resilience, legitimacy, and well-being.





Note: The work presented here includes research conducted by Dr. Alex Liu at Stanford University and that for the Global Entrepreneurship Monitoring initiative. Dr. Alex Liu greatly benefited from valuable discussions with several accomplished authors, including Danah Zohar, author of 'Spiritual Capital'; Ernie Chu, author of 'Soul Currency'; Theodore Roosevelt Malloch, author of 'Spiritual Enterprise'; and Lawrence M. Miller, author of 'The New Capitalism'.

Note: To cite us, please write "Liu, Alex. 4Capital and Performance, RM Publishing, 2008, ResearchMethods.org, https://www.researchmethods.org/4capital.htm.

 

Copyright @   The RM Institute